Key takeaway
A will is not invalid just because it is unfair. It can be set aside if it was not properly executed, if the testator lacked mental capacity, or if it was forged or obtained by fraud, coercion or undue influence. The person relying on the will must prove it and explain any suspicious circumstances. Objections are usually raised in probate proceedings or in a civil suit, and delay can defeat a strong case.
Disputes over wills are among the most bitter family cases. NRIs often learn of a will only when relatives in India start transferring property. This guide explains the grounds and the procedure.
Grounds for challenging a will
- Improper execution. The will was not signed by the testator, or not attested by two witnesses as section 63 of the Indian Succession Act requires.
- Lack of testamentary capacity. The testator was not of sound mind — for example, because of advanced dementia or illness — and did not understand what they were doing.
- Forgery. The signature or the document is fabricated.
- Fraud, coercion or undue influence. The testator’s free will was overborne, typically by someone in a position of control who benefits.
- Revocation. A later will or act revoked it.
- Disposition beyond the testator’s power. For example, a Hindu disposing of other coparceners’ shares in ancestral property, or a Muslim bequeathing more than one-third without consent.
Who has to prove what
The person relying on the will (the propounder) must prove that it was duly executed, usually by examining at least one attesting witness. The Supreme Court has long held that where there are suspicious circumstances, the propounder must remove them to the court’s satisfaction (H. Venkatachala Iyengar v. B.N. Thimmajamma, 1959). Examples include:
- the main beneficiary took a leading part in preparing the will;
- natural heirs are excluded without explanation;
- the signature is shaky or inconsistent with the testator’s condition;
- the will surfaced long after death;
- the witnesses are close associates of the beneficiary.
A person alleging fraud, coercion or undue influence must prove it.
Where to challenge
In probate or letters of administration proceedings
When someone applies for probate, notice is given to the heirs and published. Any person with an interest can file a caveat and object. The proceedings then become contentious and are tried like a suit. If probate has already been granted, an application for revocation can be made under section 263 of the Indian Succession Act on grounds such as defective proceedings or fraud.
In a civil suit
Where probate is not required, a challenge is often made in a suit for a declaration that the will is invalid, for partition treating the property as passing by intestacy, and for an injunction against transfers.
In mutation proceedings
Revenue authorities may record mutation on the basis of a will. Mutation does not decide title, but you should object in time to prevent the record being used against you.
Time limits
Different limitation periods apply depending on the proceeding. A declaratory suit or a suit to set aside an instrument is generally subject to a three-year period running from when the cause of action arose or you learned of it. A probate application by the propounder is itself subject to limitation principles developed by the courts. Seek advice as soon as you learn of the will.
Evidence to gather
- Certified copy of the will and, if registered, the registration record
- Medical records showing the testator’s condition around the date of the will
- Earlier wills, letters or statements of intention
- Specimen signatures for handwriting comparison
- Information about the witnesses and who arranged the signing
Contesting from abroad
You can file a caveat or suit through a lawyer under a vakalatnama, with affidavits sworn abroad. Evidence may be recorded by video conference where the court allows, or on commission. A relative holding your Power of Attorney can attend to documents and practical steps.
Frequently asked questions
Can I challenge a will because it leaves me nothing?
Exclusion alone is not a ground. It can be a suspicious circumstance the propounder must explain, but a person of sound mind may leave self-acquired property to anyone.
Does registration make a will unchallengeable?
No. Registration is evidence of execution, but a registered will can still be challenged for lack of capacity, undue influence or fraud.
Can a settlement be reached?
Yes. Many will disputes end in a family settlement recorded before the court.
Need help with a will dispute?
LegalCops connects NRIs with independent lawyers for probate objections and will challenges. See wills and probate for NRIs.
Doubt a will that has surfaced?
Act early. Share when you learned of it and what stage any proceedings are at.
Related guides
- All NRI legal guides
- Inheritance and succession in India: the complete guide
- How probate works in India
- Making a will in India as an NRI
- Ancestral property disputes from overseas
References
- Indian Succession Act, 1925, sections 59, 61, 63, 263 and 276–284 — India Code
- Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (proof of attested documents)
- Limitation Act, 1963
- H. Venkatachala Iyengar v. B.N. Thimmajamma, AIR 1959 SC 443
Last reviewed: November 2026.
The information provided is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Applicable laws and procedures may vary depending on the facts, jurisdiction, and circumstances of each matter. Consult a qualified legal professional before taking action.

